If someone asks for mechila is it a hiyuv to mochel him, or just a very strong etza? Also, is it permitted to forgive someone from punishment, but not be friendly with them in the future—it seems there are many cases where a person is willing to forgive from punishment, but beyond them to have much of a relationship.

Answer:

If the person asking mechilah is sincere, then there is a “moral requirement” to forgive him (see Rema 606:1). Gilyonei Ha-Shas (Yoma 87a) discusses whether or not this is an actual obligation, or only “worthy conduct,” and the latter option is the more likely: Forgiveness is something that depends on the heart, and it is not always possible to forgive; however, where it is possible, and the person in question is truly and sincerely penitent, it is worthy practice to follow the ways of Hashem, and forgive the penitent.

It is possible to forgive a person even when one is not interested in entereing into “much of a relationship” with them.

See also Sefer Hateshuvah 2:10; Shulchan Aruch Harav, 606:4.

Tags: forgive punishment

Share The Knowledge

Not what you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged Repentance The Day of Atonement (Yom Kippur) forgive punishment or ask your own question.

2 Responses to “Obligation of Forgiveness?”

  1. If does not have a relationship with offending person isn’t it revenge?

    • I don’t think so. Revenge is getting him back, or bearing a grudge. But the obligation to love others doesn’t imply entering a relationship with everyone–not everyone is my “cup of tea”, and I don’t think that merely refraining from entering a (close) relationship is vengeful. However, when said “hello” to one should reply (at least cordially)–the Gemara writes that refraining from speaking (for three days) implies hatred.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *