Is there a hidur mitzvah to first place the wick into the menorah holder and then the oil after as it was done in the bais hamikdash? Is there a source for such a hidur in halacha? Also, why don’t we light 6 candles for 8 nights as the miracle happened?

Answer:

I have never seen this hiddur, and I don’t know a source for it — although it is an interesting idea.

The enactment of the Chanukah menorah was not to light the same menorah as the Mikdash (with seven arms), but to light an eight-armed menorah in commemoration of the eight days.

Many commentaries discuss the inner significance of the eight arms of the Chanukah menorah (for instance, a popular theme is that the number eight indicates going beyond the regular order of nature, which is embodied by the number seven), though the simple significance is corresponding to the eight days, a different number of candles being lit each day to demonstrate which day of Chanukah it is.

2 Responses to “The Chanukah Menorah”

  1. We light Chanuccah in Shkiah. But it’s forbidden to light earlier or later. When Shabbat comes we cannot light before Shkiah? When Shabbat leaves we must wait an “hour” in honour of Shabbat. It means we miss two night of eight because of Shabbat prohibition?

    • The Sages were aware of this when they enacted the mitzvah of Hanukah candles, and therefore it is part of the original enactment to light early / late on Friday / Shabbos.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *