For donations Click Here

Future Graf shel Re’i

There is something that is right now muktzeh and assur b’tiltul. In a number of hours though it will become on it’s own a graf shel re’i. Is there any heter to move it now since l’maseh it will become a graf shel re’i and will then be mutar b’tiltul?

Answer:

Because right now, this is not a graf shel re’i, there does not appear to be a heter to move it now.

Chazal permit moving a graf shel re’i — see Chazon Ish 48:10 who explains that a graf shel re’i becomes a keli she-melachto heiter (though others possibly dispute this, and give a different definition) — because of the disturbance it causes to the people in its vicinity, and if it is not disturbing at the moment, there would not be a heter to move it.

A possible proof to this is the halachah of not making a graf shel re’i lechatchilah, where it seems clear that until the graf shel re’i is fully extant, there will not be permission to move it.

Best wishes.

 

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

  1. I later found these mareh makomos…

    See here teshuva from R’ Shlomo Zalman (brought in this article in Kovitz Beis Aharon V’Yisrael) who is makil
    http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=13056&st=&pgnum=65&hilite=
    (Goes through tzadidim lhachmir with many re’as however lhakil. R’ Eliyashuv is brought at the end who is machmir.)

    See Sdei Chemed (starting towards the end of sif-katan 34) here that brings the Pri Chadash and Bach that is makil however argues on them
    http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=14156&st=&pgnum=223

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *