Question: Hi, I am a graduate student and my school is having an event Friday night on a boat. I wanted to know if there are any issues with getting on the boat on Shabbos late Friday night. I will not be carrying anything on me, the boat is free, and the boat will be […]
Author Archives: Rav Baruch Rubanowitz
Emergency Powers for Beth Din
Question: Regarding Devarim 19:17, please see Gemoro Sanhedrin 46a, 81b and Yevamos 90b where it shows that the Beth Din can take extra legal powers in an emergency. What constituted an emergency? When did the emergency powers cease? Is there any record of the Beth Din / Sanhedrin actually doing this? Were there any checks […]
Can I live in the same yishuv as my ex husband ?
Question: Can I live in same yishuv as my garush (ex husband) , in the opposite end of it? We have shared custody and I have not been able to find a rental for months other than in the same yishuv Answer: You may live in the same yishuv as your ex lives in provided […]
Children’s Artwork and Avoda Zarah
Question: I made the attached piece of art in 1st grade- public school. It was well received by the school principal and hung in the school until when it was recently returned to me. The art depicts a “sun god”- we were learning about ancient egyptian religion. Is it permissible to own the item? It […]
A moon with Facial Features and Stained Glass image of Moon
Question: 1. Am I allowed to paint a moon with facial features and five pointed stars? 2. I have made a stained glass scene of a man wearing tefillin and playing a harp with a mountain and water in the background. The moon is visible in the sky and the reflection of the moon is […]
Challenging the beis din that made a mistake in their ruling
Question: If a beis din made a factual error in their ruling and later verbally acknowledged it but still is not interested to change it (we are sure they are bias), may we go to another beis din to get a “permission to go to court”? Or possibly claim the other beis din to a […]
Succah Height
Question: If 20 Amos is Halacha l’moshe misinai how can R. Yehudah dispute the Rabbis? Thank you! Answer: The gemoro at the beginning of Succa discusses many possibilities for the 20 amos height maximum for succa. While many other shiurim are halacha lemoshe misinai, height of succa is not one of them. There are […]
Will
Question: Is there a halachik obligation to write a will? If so, is there a specific way it needs to be written or can you just write one, sign it and make sure that someone else has a copy of it? Thank you. Answer: There is no halachic requirement to write a will. the Torah […]
Pronunciation of the last latter in Hebrew without a dagesh
Question: I, as an Ashkenazic Jew, am one of many with a family history of pronouncing the last Hebrew letter as saf (e.g. Berashis), however, growing up, I was often exposed to Israeli culture and their pronunciation of the letter as taf. The latter is what I adopted from an early age. However, recently, viewing […]
Loaning mony to another
Question: If I borrow money on a credit line, which I lent to another, and when this other repays me , am I allowed to accept also the interest charged to me by the bank, for the loan? Answer: Your loan from the non-Jewish credit company is your loan and you can take that out […]
Check leafy greens
Question: Hi, I have been making homemade pesto and have been checking a lot of basil leaves. I use a very high powered blender to make the pesto and its totally liquid after blending. Do I need to check the basil for bugs before blending it? Thank you, Joseph Answer: I cannot offer you […]
Bar mitzvah date conflict
Question: Dear Rabbi, My son’s birthday is כ״ו Adar- Friday The next day is Shabbat parsha Vayakel-Pekuday. However another family reserved this day already. What are our options halachically if we would like celebrate at the same Shul? Does my son get called up for an Aliya on Shabbat Vayakel-Pekuday, reciting only the brachot? Or, […]
Sukkah
Question: A larger Sukkah is being erected in a yard. Due to it’s size, some of the nearby trees/branches are hanging over part of the Sukkah. Does this invalidate the entire Sukkah, or simply the area/space covered by the tree branches? Thank You. Answer: Should the branches hang over the schach but not touch the […]
Reliance on cholov yisroel in coffee shop
Question: In response to this question – just a comment – the chassidic poskim say one cannot rely on this, b/c if the goy runs out of CY he will just add Cholov Stam to the CY bottle. Rav Belsky zatzal ruled one can rely, b/c everyone knows that pouring milk from one bottle into […]
First evidence of Mashiach
Question: Shalom, I wondered what’s the first evidence that the Jewish people believed in the concept of Mashiach (the figure of the Messainic era/age)? Of course there are well known scriptures referring to Mashiach, but there needs to be a point where we started to identify them as such. So what’s the first reference we […]
Harchakot- passing objects
Question: Is it forbidden to place an item on the lap of your wife who is a niddoh if there is no concern that you are going to touch her? The Mechaber seems to allow one to throw an item towards one wife for her to catch (seemingly because there is no concern that they […]
Received duplicate product from online company, their mistake
Question: I received a duplicate product a week after receiving the one I paid for. The company is a non-Jewish company in Utah. They would not know I am Jewish. They have not asked for the duplicate product back. Am I obligated to let them know and try to send it back? The product is […]
Maaser and charity with separate funds
Question: I have three separate bank accounts. In one of them I receive my salary. In the second one, I deposit all the maaser money. I have a question with the third one. Is it halachically permissible to use it as a separate charity fund (deducted from my salary) or is enough to use the […]
Maaser money on sale of a home
Question: I sold a home, bought an apartment, performed shipputizm on the latter, & still realized a profit. Question: am I required to give maaser on the net profit on the sale/purchase of my homes? Many thanks. Answer: Please clarify your question. Did you sell the apartment afterwards? Am I to understand that you sold […]
Non Kosher nasal drops/ spray
Question: Can one take treife nasal drops/ spray ( it has animal glycerin)? Answer: Once it is in a nasal spray or drop form, it is not edible and thus kosher. Also, since you are not ingesting it, there is no restriction to use the animal based medication. Sources:
Special Thanks!
Question: Dear rabbis, I had requested an issue concerning circumcision future concerns a few weeks and you advised me to speak to a mohel. I did and he told me I had to have another ceremonial bris milah performed. It was done today. Thank you for your help. My original circumcision was given a birth […]
siyum
Question: In response to the question about making a siyum – I wanted to point out that while indeed one can make a fleishige siyum even during the week of Tisha Bav (although, of course, there are restrictions as to who may partake of the meat at such a siyum), Rav Moshe, zt”l, felt that […]
Reliance upon non-kosher kitchen, cholov Yisroel
Question: Is one allowed to buy coffee from a non-Jewish shop that has Cholov Yisrael? Must I be concerned that the non-Jew will change the milk? Answer: The question is vague and I will try to address a number of scenarios. There is a situation in which you know that in the past the […]
9 the day of av
Question: We are Sephardic and we have been building our new home for the past 18 months. We plan to move at the end of the month and everyday lost is money lost. Can we allow the workers to continue on the 9th day of Av? Answer: Sepharadim have refrained from […]
Using Microwave Ovens for Dairy and Meat
Question: I am curious about the use of microwave ovens for both milchig and fleishig. Is it permissible to use a microwave for both as long as they are covered and the microwave is kept clean, or is it preferable to use it for only one or the other? Does using a milk plate […]
Praises of G-d in Tenach
Question: On Devorim 4:4 Ohr Hachaim (p. 1792) says we don’t find expressions of praise for G-d in Tenach. This is because he doesn’t want the hosts of Heaven to praise him until the jews have done so. What about lord of hosts? What about Devorim 10:17? Answer: Reading from the original Hebrew, I understand […]
lifnei iver
Question: My Jewish boss is not religious and ordered non-kosher food from a restaurant that has kosher and non-kosher food. He asked his religious Jewish employee to go and pick up the order in the restaurant (maris ayin is not an issue since the restaurant also contains kosher foods). May the employee pick up the […]
Seudas hoda’ah during the nine days
Question: My life was in danger and my life was spared by an event that I attribute to Hashem’s intervention. Is it permissible or advisable to have a seudas hoda’ah every year with meat/wine on the anniversary of this event? If yes, who would be permitted to attend? Answer: If a person recognizes that he […]
Social services
Question: THE FAMILY HAD FOR 30 YEARS BEING SUFFERING UNDER MALICIOUS AND UNPROVEN ALLEGATIONS THAT HAD UP UNTIL TODAY DESTROYED THE FAMLY. OUR DAUGHTER HAD JUST GIVEN BIRTH, AND NOW OUR DAUGHTER HAD BEEN BLACKMAIL TO EITHER GO WITH THE SOCIAL SERVICES OR HER DAUGHTER WILL BE TAKEN AWAY. MY QUESTIONS IS FOR THESES KIND […]
Can a Righteous person father an evil Person?
Question: Ramban (Netzovim 29:17) writes that anyone whose heart is with G-d will not have an idolatrous child. Is he saying that anyone who is righteous will have righteous offspring? What about Yishai who never sinned, but his son David did sin? See also King Yosam son of Uzziah described in Succah 45b. He had […]
9 Days – Ironing out 1 wrinkle
Question: Is it permissible to iron 1 wrinkle/crease that is on the cuff of my pants during the 9 days? Answer: Shulchan Aruch forbids ironing from Rosh Chodesh until after the fast.[1] While there are various interpretations for the Hebrew word gihutz, Rav Moshe Feinstein confirms that the activity which we call ironing with an […]
9 Days – Wearing new belt- Shabbos Chazon
Question: Before Rosh Chodesh Av I purchased a new belt. I tired it on at the store and after Rosh chodesh I would like to wear it. May I wear a new belt during the none days? If not, May I wear it on Shabbos Chazon? Answer: During the nine days there are numerous restrictions. […]
Contributing to the Community Eruv
Question: Are members of a community required to contribute to a community eruv in order to use it? What in the city would disqualify having an eruv? Answer: Generally, all residents should contribute towards such communal needs as a shul, a sefer Torah, and chessed funds. Even if one were to claim that he […]