To Donate Click Here

Legitimacy of the Rabbinate



1. Do you feel it is a legitimate halachic opinion to reject the legitimacy of the modern day orthodox rabbinate?

2. Where does the modern day orthodox rabbinate draw its legitimacy?

3. Can you offer a good resource on the halachic development of conversion?

4. Is the rabbinate a purely political institution?


Here are some answers to your questions:

1-2 The rabbinate, no matter which type, draws it legitimacy and is considered legitimate is so far that it is loyal to the divine torah that we received on Mt. Sinai, which includes the written law in the bible, and the oral law (the mesorah), which is the Mishnayos, and the talmud. To the degree that ones halachic opinion is coming from the torah and the mesorah, it is legitimate, and whenever it is coming from interests to change the torah or “adopt” it to what is convenient for us it is not legitimate.

3. Tractate Bechoros 30b, Rambam (Maimonidies) Eisurei Biah 14, Tur and Shulchan Aruch Yoreh Deah 268, Igrot Moshe Yoreh Deah  vol. 3- 106, 108

4. I don’t know what “Rabbinate” you are referring to.



Join the Conversation


  1. Thank you for posting. Ultimately a supposedly Halachic jew who has poor middot is not really following halacha, correct? Since we are tasked with walking in the way of Gd.

    1. I don’t get the connection between this and the answer to the question.
      Being a halachic Jew and having poor middot is definitely not a good thing and we are commanded to walk in Gods ways, however perfecting our personalities is a lifetimes worth of work. No one was born an angel. We definitely can not compare a person who wants to do gods will, but hasn’t yet fully developed his personality, to someone that wants to bend the torah and mitzvot to his prefferance

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *