For donations Click Here

Shemonah Esrai when possibly not clean after bathroom

Question:

If an individual flatulated before the Amidah and then again after the Amida and when he went to wipe that area noticed that it was brown (on the paper with which he wiped himself). Does he have to repeat the Amida (Shemonah Esrah)?

Answer:

Hello,

You do not have to repeat Shemona Esrai since it is only a very small amount and a safek (a case of doubt) in a derabbanan.

All the best

 

Sources:

MIshna Berura 76:17 (machlokes Chayai Adam and Mishna Berura). Rav Akiva Eiger 7, Magen Avraham 585:3, Pischei Teshuva Y:D 110:20. Eshel Avraham Mi’Butchach 76:5.

In addition, a single (i.e. not all 3 in a day) Shemona Esrai is Mi’derabbanan.

 

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *