For Donations Click Here

Shvus d'shvus by amira lenochri

Question:

Whenever there is a heter of shvus deshvus on shabbos in a case of mitzvah to ask a goy should it preferably be with a hint because there is a machlokes if shvus deshvus is muttar in the first place?

Thank you

 

Answer:

Hello,

I am not sure what machlokes you are referring to, and inn general you do not have to hint it. However see מלכים אומניך פ"ד הערה ד' what he writes there about a similar question.

Best wishes  

 

Join the Conversation

2 Comments

  1. I was asking because in shulchan aruch 307:5 there is an opinion that a double derabbanan is assur to ask a goy except by bris milah so do we need to hint to accomidate that opinion

    1. Very nice. The Mishna Berura 306-23, says that we don’t pasken like this shit”a, but now I understand your question better.
      Thanks.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *