For Donations Click Here

follow up on a question that i asked regarding matir neder

Question:

on 2/11/2026 i asked the following question

Question:
A few years ago, I was matir neder on a few things. Before I was matir neder, I told my husband (and thought) that I don’t have an issue and that I might even want to continue doing the things I’m being matir neder for, but without the pressure of it being a neder. After he was matir the neder, I said very clearly that anything I continue doing is only bli neder. A few years passed, and it is becoming difficult for me to continue doing these things. My question is whether it’s okay to stop doing these things without being matir neder again, given that at that time I thought and said I don’t mind or even want to continue doing them (but without pressure)?

and your answer was:

Answer:
Hello,

From what you are writing, it seems that you did want to continue doing the good things; however, you just wanted to remove the stigma of it being a neder. Additionally, you stated clearly that whatever you continue doing is bli neder. Therefore, you may stop what you are doing if it is difficult for you, and you shouldn’t be concerned that it might have turned into a neder again.

Best wishes.

I followed up with this question on 2/16/2026:
Following your response to my question titled 'Matir neder question' posted on 02/11/2026, I have one more question. I know that thought could be binding in halacha. Therefore, I would like to ask if even though I was matir neder, and said with my mouth clearly that whatever I continue doing is bli neder, in my mind I still carried anxiety of letting go of the neder and so i continued doing it. But again, I clearly said with my mouth then that I'm continuing to do it bli neder. I want to know if those fearful thoughts bind me to the neder in any way. Thank you.

and your answer was:

Answer:
You didn't want to stop doing the good that were doing, and you only wanted to get rid of the stigma of the neder. Which you did, and everything is fine. There is no need to be anxious over this.

I am following up with the below response because my question did not come across clearly. Please clarify. Thank you!

Correct, but now I do want to stop doing it. My question is if those anxious thoughts that kept me doing the neder until now, binds me to it in any way-now that I want to stop doing it.
and thats why i reiterated in my question that I clearly said at the time that i was matir neder (which was several years ago) that whatever i continue doing is only bli neder. Please clarify. Thank you.

 

Answer:

Thank you for making things clearer for me.

You may stop doing these things, if you wish to do so. You are not bound by any neder, because you were matir the neder, and you specified verbally that if yo do continue that it is bli neder, meaning that no neder should apply. That s exactly what happened. You continued doing what you did, without the stigma of the neder. Therefore, if you do stop now, there is no neder that existed, and you didn't break anything.

The fact that a person can be bound to a thought is regarding tzedakah, but here you said specifically that you don't want it to be a neder.

I hope this clarifies this.

Best wishes

Sources:

 

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *