For Donations Click Here

Uncle passed away, sons not frum

Question:

My uncle passed away yesterday, he was not frum and has two sons who are also not. My parents are both still living (I am assuming therefore I shouldn't say kaddish for him) and I am wondering what is the best thing that my sons and I can do for his neshama.
Also, how diligent should we be about finding someone else to say kaddish for him? My father (the niftar's brother in law) is the only relative I know of who davens with a minyan somewhat regularly and has no living parents. But even he does not daven with a minyan everyday.
Another point - it is highly unlikely that the niftar will ever have anyone named after him or any Jewish grandchildren at all. Is that something to take into account for some of his frum nieces/nephews still having children?
Thank you for your guidance.

 

Answer:

Hello,
It is good that you are caring for your uncle’s neshama. You and your sons can learn Mishnayos and say the tefilla, “ana Hashem…” afterwards. Your father can say kaddish when he is davening with a minyan. If you want, you can pay someone to say kaddish, but you are not required to do this.
As far as naming your children after him, sadly, the fact that no one will be named after your uncle is not something you need to consider. From what you wrote, it seems your cousins married out, so their children are not considered Jewish. One reason to name a child after someone is to connect the child’s neshama to the niftar, which is why we often name after tzadikim. If your uncle did not live the way you hope your children will, you would not want to give them that name or its spiritual influence (see Rashi Yuma 38b D:H d’lo maski, Maharsha Taanis 28a D:H Hu omer, Shut Chasam Sofer 2 Even Haezer 25). We are not here to judge, and we do not know the challenges the older generation faced. Still, since he and his children are not religious, you would not want your children or grandchildren to follow that path, God forbid.
Best wishes

 

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *