Question:
Hi,
I wanted to ask a halachic question regarding shill bidding in a live-stream auction.
We sell through live auctions, and occasionally we start an item at $1 in order to create excitement and encourage bidding. However, in order to protect ourselves from taking a significant loss, we sometimes have someone bid on our behalf and bring the price up to a certain minimum amount that we are willing to accept.
The person bidding on our behalf is not actually intending to purchase the item. If that bidder ends up winning the auction, we absorb the approximately 10% platform fee, so there is a real cost to us when that happens.
We never use the shill bidder to bring the item above what we consider its normal or fair selling price. We specialize in wholesale pricing and generally sell our products at very competitive prices. The purpose is only to protect ourselves from an unreasonable loss while still being able to start items at $1 and make the livestream more exciting.
My question is: Is this practice permitted according to halacha? Could it be considered geneivat da'at, particularly when the buyers are non-Jews, since the other bidders believe they are bidding against a genuine customer? Are there any other halachic issues that we should be concerned about with this practice?
Thank you very much.
Answer:
Hello,
What you are doing is essentially geneivas daas: fooling the customer into thinking he will get a great deal when that isn't really possible. While it can't be said that it is clearly illegal, the FTC considers it a fraudulent practice. Regarding the halachos of geneivas daas, this would depend on how common the practice is and to what degree bidders in an auction should know this is what is being done to them. Perhaps it might be considered as if the person "fooled himself" if it is a very common occurrence. I don't have that information, so I cannot answer you.
Best wishes