Question:
Is it lashon hara if two people are learning and one says, "From here we see that Shimon (a different person) is wrong" (basically, he is wrong in saying ...)? If it's during learning, is it considered lashon hara to tell his chavrusah that Shimon is wrong, even though he didn't mean to embarrass Shimon at all?
Answer:
Hello,
If it is done for the sake of learning, then it is permitted as it is considered l’toseles. However, if the intention is to bash Shimon, then it is lashon hora.
Best wishes