Question:
Hello.
If the Ba'al HaTefilla missed an important section of Chazaras HaShatz (during the weekdays) (a section that would necessitate repetition if said silently, e.g., HaMelech HaKadosh or Ya'aleh V'Yavo), should the Chazaras HaShatz be repeated? By the same Ba'al HaTefilla? By another Ba'al HaTefilla? If yes and if it were to happen in a Tzibur where the Kohanim duchen, would the Kohanim duchen a second time? Mareh Mekomos would be appreciated.
Thank you.
Answer:
It depends on where he was holding when the mistake was realized. In general, whenever a private person goes back, if the Baal Tefillah made such a mistake in chazora hashatz, he also goes back. (However, there are some differences; see O:CH siman 126 1-3, with Mishna Berura.) The chazzan himself can be the one to repeat it. Regarding Birkas Kohanim, if the same tzibbur is there and it is the same tefillah, Birkas Kohanim will not be repeated; however, the chazzan will say elokeinu velokei avoseinu. See Piskei Teshuvos 126-11.
Best wishes
Sources: