For Donations Click Here

Pidyon Nefesh – Facts and Functions

 

In this week’s article, we will discuss the concept of Pidyon Nefesh, defining what is it and its sources in the Torah; how it helps and to whom. Can it atone for intentional aveiros? Is it effective only during one’s lifetime, or can it also help posthumously? To whom is the money given, and how is Pidyon Nefesh done nowadays? What sum should be given?

We will also discuss the significance of Haman’s ten thousand bars of silver. How much were they actually worth, and how much would they be worth today? How did the Machatzis HaShekel, the half-shekel that each Jew gave, outweigh Haman’s bars of silver? Can a Pidyon Nefesh help a rasha? Is Kaddish effective for all deceased Jews? How is Pidyon Nefesh performed for a rasha? These questions and others will be discussed in this week’s article.

Human Value

In this week’s parashah, the Torah tells us (Bereshis 14:21): “And the king of Sedom said to Avram, ‘Give me the people, and take the possessions for yourself.’” This pasuk teaches us that even the king of Sedom understood that human beings cannot be reduced to monetary value or compared to material possessions. He therefore pleaded with Avraham Avinu to take all the legendary wealth of Sedom, and leave him the people.

Everyone understands that money cannot alleviate emotional, spiritual, or physical pain, or bring the deceased back to life. In that case, what is Pidyon Nefesh? How does it work? Can money actually correct something or help change a judgement?

Before Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, we dedicated this space to this question in a more general approach: what can we do to elevate the souls of our deceased lived ones. This week we will focus on a more specific question: What is Pidyon Nefesh? Is it fact or fiction? Does it really help?

Money for Spirit

Rav Yosef Chaim Zonnenfeld (Toras Chaim 86) was asked if there is a source for making a Pidyon Nefesh for someone who has passed away, and whether it is effective.

Rav Yosef Chaim answered that the source for the concept of Pidyon Nefesh is in the Torah (Shemos 21:30), where the Torah discusses a shor muad – an ox that was known to gore people, that actually killed a person. Although its owner is liable to death, the Torah requires him to redeem this liability with a monetary payment to the heirs. This is the source for the concept of Pidyon Nefesh: in certain circumstances, a soul can be redeemed by paying a sum corresponding to his value.

Here, the Torah establishes a fixed sum of thirty shekels. A shekel normally values four zuz, but we know that the Torah here refers to a shekel tzuri, which is worth eight times as much. Thus, each shekel is worth twenty-four zuz, making the value of a human being, as set by the Torah, 720 zuz.

To give us an idea of how much we are talking about, the Gemara tells us that a person's annual living expenses is 200 zuz. In other words, 720 zuz is enough to support a person for three years and a little over seven months.

Rav Yosef Chaim cites another source for Pidyon Nefesh from the Tanach. In (Shmuel I 14:45) we learn of a special Cherem declared by Shaul, imposing death on anyone who would violate it. Yehonoson, Shaul’s son, was unaware of the cherem, and violated it. However, instead of being put to death, the people redeemed him: “Vayifdu ha'am es Yehonasan velo meis” — “And the people redeemed Yehonasan, and he did not die.”

The Radak cites the words of Rabbi Eliezer in the Midrash, explaining that Klal Yisrael weighed Yehonasan and donated gold in his weight to Hekdesh. Through this tremendous contribution, he was saved from the death penalty.

This, explains Rav Yosef Chaim Zonnenfeld, is a source establishing that Pidyon Nefesh can be performed for an unintentional aveirah.

Where the Money Goes

Rav Yosef Chaim Zonnenfeld adds that when the Beis Hamikdash stood, or there was a Mizbe’ach in Nov, a Pidyon Nefesh for an aveira could be donated to Hekdesh, to be used on these sacred sites.

Similarly, when one causes harm to another because of his negligence — for example, by failing to properly secure his ox — he must give the redemption payment to the victim’s heirs.

Where can one contribute his Pidyon Nefesh money nowadays, without a Beis Hamikdash? Rav Yosef Chaim cites the Gemara (Bava Basra 9a) that nowadays, Hekdesh is given to tzedakah.

The Tanna Devei Eliyahu (Eliyahu Rabbah 11) records a story with a similar message. There were two families of Kohanim whose children all died in adolescence. Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai told them that if they descended from the family of Eli HaKohen, whose descendants had been cursed with premature death, they should give the value of each son to tzedakah once he reached maturity in accordance with the pasuk (Mishlei 10:2): “U'tzedakah tatzil mimaves” — “And charity saves from death.”

Eliyahu HaNavi concludes: “They went and did so, and they saved themselves from death. Not only that, but one who practices justice and charity and sustains many lives, as the pasuk states (Tehillim 55:19): ‘Padah beshalom nafshi’ — ‘He redeemed my soul in peace.’”

This holds true also for non-Jews. Daniel (4:24) advised Nevuchadnezzar to correct his sins through charity, and save himself from the decree that had been issued against him.

There are also numerous other psukim about tzedakah atoning for aveiros, such as Mishlei 16:6: “B'chesed ve'emes yechupar avon” — “Through kindness and truth, sin is atoned for.”

These sources teach us that tzedakah can correct and alleviate evil decrees and intentional and deliberate sins.

Physical or Spiritual Redemption

The above sources teach us that tzedakah can save one from physical decrees – death in this world. But does tzedakah help in the Next World? Can a sinner be spared his punishment by monetary payments made on his behalf in this world? After all, Nevuchadnezzar was ultimately condemned to eternal punishment in Sheol despite all the charity he had distributed (Yeshayahu 14:3–23).

Rav Yosef Chaim points out that this question is discussed in the Gemara (Bava Basra 10a). The concept that tzedakah saves from death appears twice in Mishlei: (10:2) “Lo yo'ilu otzros resha, utzedakah tatzil mimaves” — “Treasures of wickedness do not profit, but tzedakah saves from death.” And also: (11:4): “Lo yo'il hon beyom evrah, utzedakah tatzil mimaves” — “Wealth does not help on the day of wrath, but tzedakah saves from death.” The Gemara asks: why is the same idea repeated in almost identical language? And it answers that the first pasuk teaches that tzedakah saves a person from unnatural premature death in This World. One who gives tzedakah appropriately, in proportion to his means, can be spared an unnatural death and merit to live all the years he is allotted. The second pasuk teaches how tzedakah saves one in the eternal World to Come. One who gave tzedakah appropriately can be spared eternal punishment in Gehenom which is called “the day of wrath.”

Tzedakah Distributed Posthumously

Based on these sources, Rav Yosef Chaim Zonnenfeld understands that Pidyon Nefesh funds distributed by a person during his lifetime can indeed save him from punishments for his aveiros, including death and Gehinom, whether the aveiros were committed unintentionally or intentionally.

After he is gone, his family or loved ones can also make a Pidyon Nefesh on his behalf to save his neshamah from the judgments of the World of Truth. Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld points to the parashah of Eglah Arufah as proof: The Torah states (Devarim 21:8): “Kaper le'amcha Yisrael asher padisa Hashem” — “Atone for Your people Yisrael, whom You have redeemed, Hashem.” The Sifrei (210) explains this pasuk: “‘For Your people’ refers to the living; ‘whom You have redeemed’ refers to the deceased.” This, explains Rabbi Zonnenfeld, teaches us that Pidyon Nefesh can also be performed on behalf of the deceased.

Indeed, this ruling is recorded in the Shulchan Aruch (OC 621:6) and the Rema (YD 249:16). The Gra (YD 249:21) notes that the Rema's source is the Sifrei, and the aforementioned Gemara (Bava Basra 10a) concerning the pasuk “U'tzedakah tatzil mimaves.” (Our Rosh Hashanah 5787 article discusses the effective and ineffective forms of tzedakah.)

Rav Yosef Chaim Zonnenfeld concludes with the Gemara (Horayos 6a): although atonement is not ordinarily possible for the deceased, and one who has died can no longer atone for his aveiros independently, the deceased can be included in atonement for the living.

Therefore, he writes, practically, when performing Pidyon Nefesh for someone who has passed away, it is important to also make a Pidyon Nefesh for the living and do teshuvah and improve one’s own deeds, particularly those in which the deceased was lax. When the living does teshuva and atones for his sins, he can include the deceased in that atonement as well.

The Amount

Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld also addresses the question of the amount. How much should be given for Pidyon Nefesh?

At first glance it would seem that one should give his monetary value, as though he were being sold as a slave. However, Rav Yosef Chaim points out, the Torah mentions different amounts for Pidyon Nefesh. Yehonasan, the royal prince, was redeemed for his weight in gold, while one whose ox killed a person pays thirty shekels. Although this is also a substantial sum, it is nowhere near his weight in gold. And Pidyon HaBen, the mitzva of Redeeming the Firstborn, is done with five silver shekels. Why are there discrepancies? What is the reason for the different sums?

Human Value

In parashas Erchin the Torah establishes different monetary values for different people. The value of a one-month-old male is five shekels, while a female of the same age it is three. From five years till twenty, a person’s value rises to 20 shekels for a male and 10 shekels for a female. Between twenty and sixty, a person’s value rises once more, and a male is worth 50 shekels, while a female is worth 30. After sixty, one’s value drops: a male is valued at 15 shekels, while a female is valued at ten.

A shekel is worth 20 grams of silver. To calculate the value of these shekels today, multiply the number of shekels by 20 grams of silver, and then calculate it value according to the current price of silver.

But there is another Pidyon Nefesh mentioned in the Torah: the half-shekel, given by all Jewish people as “a ransom for the soul” (kofer nefesh). How did the huge amounts of silver shrink to a half-shekel?

Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld explains that when giving ma’aser from one's produce, one must give a tenth of a tenth — that is, 1% of his produce. With that donation Hashem regards it as if he has given everything he has to Hashem.

The Torah values an adult male between 20-60 years at fifty shekels. His Kofer Nefesh should have been fifty shekels, but Hashem cares for Am Yisroel’s money, and asks for only 1% of that, i.e. a half-shekel.

Now we can understand why Haman gave Achashverosh 10 thousand bars of silver in exchange for his agreement to kill all the Jews. Each bar (kikar) was worth 3,000 shekels, making the total amount he was offering thirty million shekels. This corresponds to the 600,000 members of Klal Yisrael, multiplied by fifty shekels per person.

Think of it. Haman paid Achashverosh 600,000 kilograms of silver, an equivalent of annual living expenses for 4.8 million people.

The Midrash tells us that when Haman discovered that the decree had been annulled because of the half-shekel contributions, he lamented his misfortune. Why? Because Hashem's shekels had preceded theirs. He realized that through every Jew contributing just one percent of his full valuation, Klal Yisrael had been protected and saved, even though Haman had offered Achashverosh their full value.

Rav Yosef Chaim therefore concludes that a half-shekel is sufficient to protect a person. At times, however, a decree has already been issued, and the full value of the person may be necessary to save him.

Practically, how much should be given for Pidyon Nefesh? The amount, explains Rav Zonnenfeld, depends on the severity of the sin and the decree, as well as every person’s financial circumstances. A person's value can be assessed in different ways, and there is no uniform system.

Pidyon Nefesh for a Rasha

Can Pidyon Nefesh help the soul of a rasha?

In Shu”t Binyamin Ze'ev (203), the author relates the story of two Jews who were born in the region of Puglia, in southern Italy. When Charles VIII, king of Venice invaded the region, local mobs and priests forced all Jews to convert to Christianity. The two men fled the region and did teshuvah.

Their fathers, however, did not have a chance to escape. Both had died in the area, without returning to Yiddishkeit. However, the first man's father had repeatedly expressed his longing to leave and return to Yiddishkeit, but was murdered by a bandit before he could leave and complete his teshuvah. The second man's father died a natural death in his own home, in the presence of other newly converted members of the community.

As there was only one shul and one minyan in their area and both sons wanted to recite Kaddish for their fathers, and they asked if they should divide the Kaddish between them, or perhaps one of them should receive precedence and recite all the Kaddishim in the shul.

Rav Binyamin Ze'ev answered that Kaddish and Pidyon Nefesh cannot benefit someone who converted and didn’t want to live a Jewish life.

Although the Gemara does discuss was a case in which Rabbi Akiva helped a rasha by teaching his son to recite Kaddish for him, there is a distinction here: that father did not reject the Torah. He was just overcome by his Yetzer Hara.

In this case, however, the father had abandoned Yiddishkeit altogether. He had died a natural death, surrounded by other forced converts. He did not say viduy or confess his sins before his death. It is therefore quite possible that Kaddish would not benefit him at all.

The first father's situation was different. He had intended to flee the region that was forcing him to behave like a non-Jew. He had regretted his sins and wanted to reverse the situation, but was prevented from doing so because he was murdered. Furthermore, since he was murdered, he had no opportunity to confess before his death, and we cannot assume that he failed to repent. Therefore, it stands to reason that Kaddish would benefit his neshamah, and the son of the murdered father should be given precedence and recite all the Kaddishim in the shul.

This ruling is recorded in the Magen Avraham (132:2).

The Mishnah Brurah (621:19), based on the Rokeach (217) explains why Pidyon Nefesh works. If one was poor and didn’t have the means to give tzedakah but genuinely wished to do so, a contribution made on his behalf after his death expresses his original intention and is born of it. Therefore, it elevates his neshamah. However, a rasha who didn’t have such intentions, cannot benefit from it after his death.

The Or HaChaim, (Rishon LeTzion, YD 249:16), explains that this applies specifically to the aveirah committed by the deceased. If there is a specific mitzva that was close to his heart, one can donate towards that mitzva. Then, the donation will elevate his neshamah.

Therefore, for one who completely abandoned Judaism, took no interest in Jewish life, and was particularly anti-religious, there is no way to bring about an iluy neshamah, because he rejected the mitzvos during his lifetime. The principle “Ein kategor na'aseh sanegor” — an accuser cannot become a defender — applies here. Performing a mitzvah for his neshamah may arouse prosecution against him, since he himself had no desire for that mitzvah while alive.

However, someone who cherished even only one mitzva, despite being wicked in other parts of his life, can benefit if that same mitzvah is performed for his neshamah.

The Or HaChaim relates a story about the spirit of a wicked man that entered a young unmarried girl — a case of dybbuk. The spirit told those present that donating oil to light up the beis midrash and shul at night would elevate his soul, because the light would enable people to pray and learn Torah at night, and this mitzvah would benefit his neshamah.

Thus, although he had been a rasha, he had not rejected this particular mitzvah, and performing it on his behalf could benefit his soul.

 

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *