Question: What is the reason Sukkos is for 7 days? Pesach I understand because the Jews left on 15 Nissan and the Exodus culminated seven days later with Krias yam suf 7 days later. Kabbalas HaTorah was one day so it makes sense that Torah has it celebrated for one day. Was there something that […]
Author Archives: Rabbonim of the Beis Hora'a
Is it still Kosher?
Question: Was this non-kosher? If so, is there anything to do about it? I spent the holidays with relatives, who do not keep a kosher home. They koshered their oven, bought all kosher food, and used disposable and/or new plates and utensils. I just learned that when they prepared the roasted chicken, they used a […]
Jigsaw Puzzle of a Japanese Budhist Temple?
Question: Is it permitted to make a jigsaw puzzle of a zen japanese temple, would it be considered עבודה זרה? Answer: It is would technically be permitted, however from a Jewish halachic aspect it is a very distasteful thing to make. We are to distance ourselves from avoda zara in every way possible. Building such […]
Swimming pool for chafifa
Question: Can I use a swimming pool instead of a bath in preparation for the mikvah? I’m on vacation with my family and my room does not have a tub, I was wondering if I stay in the pool with modest swimming attire (long sleeves and skirt) can that be used instead of a half […]
not absolutely necessary food purchase on chol hoamoed
Question: hello, is it permitted to buy food on chol hoamoed even if it could have been purchased before? (e.g. if we buy ice cream to have during the week even though it is not perishable and therefore could have been bought before yom tov?) We do not NEED it. Answer: Food items may be […]
Tashlich at night
Question: Is tashlich said at night after tzais hakochavim ok? Or do i need to say it again? Thank you Answer: Although we try to say tashlich until nighttime, if it wasn’t, but was said at might, you don’t say it again. This is because according to some opinions, we can say it at night. […]
Purchase on chol hmoed
Question: I want to know if i can order on chol hmoed a certain colour of paint if there is only one left and it’s hard to get it. or its still better to avoid buying anything on chol hmoed. Answer: If it is hard to get otherwise, and not easy to get it after […]
mincha for women
Question: B”H Thank you for your help, it is really appreciated. If a woman bli neder wants to begin praying mincha, but does not know for sure if she will be able to do so regularly, does she need to say bli neder before every mincha, or can she say bli neder before one mincha […]
mikvah
Question: B”H Thank you for your help. Regarding when a husband and wife are intimate, and then after the act is completed, and they separate, does the wife go back to the mikvah again after every act of completed intimacy between her and her husband, or does she go once to the mikvah after her […]
Giving my Lulav to my wife who is in aveilus
Question: Can I give my lulav set to my wife so she can do the mitzvah even though she is in aveilus and cannot receive gifts? If yes, why is it allowed? Answer: Yes you can, and it isn’t considered giving her a present since it is only in order to fulfill the mitzva, and […]
Various chol hamoed questions
Question: B”H Thank you for your help. Regarding permissible activities on chol hamoed: 1. May a person move/ sort/ organize boxes of papers/ books/ items stored in order to beautify a room in the house (essentially moving boxes of things not needed for the holiday from one room to another) for the purpose of making […]
Mixed Swimming
Question: May a women and 10 year old girl go to a large mixed water park of wearing tzniut swimwear? Answer: Please see the follwing post where a similar question was discussed. https://dinonline.org/2018/09/02/what-is-the-issur-for-a-lady-to-go-mixed-swimming-if-she-is-fully-dressed/ A good moed
Making a koshekol on chol hamoed
Question: Is it permitted to make a koshekol on chol hamoed for the arba minim? Does it matter if it’s “easy” for the person to make? Answer: It is permitted to make a koshikol, because it is tzorech mitzva overes, needed for a time related mitzva. A gut moed Sources: O:CH 545-3
Patur from sukkah if sun gives headache
Question: I very easily get headaches from even very short amounts of time in the sun. Am I patur from eating in the sukkah whilst the sukkah is still the sun? Thanks for this great service Answer: Something doesn’t sound right. Your succah should not have so much sun, and even if one part of […]
Knas for neder
Question: I made a neder to hashem that if I do zera levatala without distracting myself for 30 minutes first ill pay 350$ knas and if I distract myself for 30 minutes than knas is 250$. I made the neder for 7 days at a time but I fell 2 times on day 6 which totaled 600$. this neder was […]
Bracha on smelling Esrog on Succos
Question: Can the Rav please clarify whether after shaking the lulav and esrog, people should be discouraged from smelling the esrog, as per the end of OC siman 116 that says it’s a safek whether to make a bracha? Also, even if someone is holding an esrog not for the mitzva, but just to smell, […]
Meaningful shapes on Shabbat/ Yom Tov
Question: B”H Thank you for your help. My questions are: 1. If a closed book has some dirt on the outside pages, and when separated for reading, the configuration of the stain gets separated, is it ok to open and read this book on Shabbat/ Yom Tov (the stains could be food/ drink from meals […]
Status of fleishig sink
Question: If dairy bowl not containing milk was washed in fleishig sink does sink need to be kashered? Answer: No the sink is still fleishig, because no actual milk got absorbed in the sink Have a good yom tov Sources:
Chol Hoamoed Sukkot meals
Question: Hello, I am new to much of these observances and have read conflicting things. During chol hoamoed, it is an obligation to eat two bread meals, or is that just considered “even better”? And does it apply to women, even though not obligated to eat in the Sukkah? Thank you for your time. Answer: […]
Second day of Yom Tov
Question: I want to know if on the second day of Sukkot and on Shemini Atzeret it is off-limits on Yom Tov and that includes switching on or off electrical appliances, driving a car, going to work, handling money and writing. The major differences between the two are cooking and baking, lighting a fire from […]
Sign and deposit checks on Chol Hamoed
Question: If my pay check comes on Chol Hamoed can I sign and deposit the check on Chol Hamoed? Thank you Answer: If it is needed for chol hamoed or yom tov, yes, if not it should wait. Have a good yom tov
Eating fish cooked with fleishig utensils after drinking coffee in a milchig mug
Question: Is it an issue if you eat fish and salad prepared with a fleishig knife after you drink black coffee in a milchig mug? Answer: No it is not an issue. Drinking a black coffee will not make you milchig, even if it was in a milchig mug. Have a good yom tov
Eating Kosher in Sukkah
Question: I am in the process of becoming more observant of the Mitzvos, including Kashrut, however my family’s kitchen isn’t completely Kosher and it is very hard for me to access kosher food so often I end up eating non-kosher food. However, on Sukkos I would like to fulfill the obligation of sitting and eating […]
Tzedakah question
Question: Years ago, I used to collect money for various tzedakah causes. At one point I borrowed some money from the funds collected (I know I probably shouldn’t have) with the intent to pay it back quickly. (We’re talking around a few hundred dollars) As time went by, I forget to pay it back, and […]
Can Hoshanos be said by someone davening at home?
Question: Can Hoshanos be said by someone davening at home and if yes, can or should they hold Arba Minim whilst doing so Thank you Answer: You can say hoshanos when daveng at home, and you should hold the Arba minim when saying them. Have a good Yom Tov
Opening Aravos bag
Question: Can I open the sealed packages of Aravos and Haddasim on Yom Tov itself as they remaining fresher in the sealed packages? Answer: Opening the bag in a way that ruins it, is permitted on Yom Tov, however the hadasim should be tied to the lulav and should not be tied on Yom Tov. […]
Sukka in third floor
Question: Hi, I live on the third floor of an apartment building, but built my sukka in the parking lot. I have 2 questions: 1 – Can I wash before kiddush, so I don’t have to go up and down again? 2 – If I am embarrassed to walk through the building in my pajamas, […]
Hot Pareve pot, flieshig fork
Question: Cooked pasta in pareve pot. Accidentally used clean Stainless steel flieshig fork from drainer to stir food while boiling. Fork was Not used since day before. Unsure when fork was last used. Since from drainer most likely was used yesterday. Possibly with meat food. Is pot still pareve? Can left over of that pasta […]
Metztaar potur min hasuka
Question: Hi! Thank you so much for such an amazing website! I live on the fourth floor of a very high building in Jerusalem, while my sukka is on the ground. Unfortunately, due to building issues, I am unable to use the roof for my sukka. To get to my sukka is quite the hassle, […]
Being comfortable in the sukkah
Question: If there is a person in the sukkah who smells, or I don’t feel comfortable being near him for whatever reason, am I pottur from sukkah? Answer: Try moving to a different part of the sukkah, or try to find a different succah to sit in. specially if it isn’t your succah and you […]
Follow up to original urn question
Question: Hi I forgot an an important piece of information regarding my original message about the urn so I’ll repost the whole message about that and add that piece of information which may or may not change original psak So I mistakenly put the wrong disposable hot cup under my urn this morning to make […]
Women sitting in the Sukka
Question: What is the difference of halacha for Ashkinaz and Sephardic women to sit in the Sukka and shake the lulav and Etrog? Thanks Answer: The Sefardi minhag is that women do not make a bracha on sitting in the succah of shaking the lulav. The reason being that they are patur from these time […]
Times of Divine Judgement and Mercy
Question: I’m having some trouble comprehending the Kabbalistic concept of HaShem’s different attributes at different times of day. Supposedly HaShem’s Divine Mercy occurs after midnight (hence why there is the opinion that selichot should only be said after this time). Could you please explain this concept – where is it from and where is it […]
Milky microwave – parev toaster
Question: Can I defrost bread in a milky microwave and then toast it in a parev toaster? Lchatchila would this be ok? And bdieved would it? Thank you Answer: It is a risky thing to do, because if the microwave has milk spilled on the bottom of the plate etc. then the bread is actually […]
Urn spout fleishig?
Question: I mistakenly put the wrong hot cup under my urn this morning to make coffee. I had taken a clean one from the cabinet and put it down. I guess I got distracted because when I actually went to make the coffee I realized I mistakenly used a cup that was used to serve […]
Regarding Steam
Question: My fleishig sink was clogged and a plumber poured hot water straight from the hot water urn into the fleishig sink. Being that the sink wasn’t clean and there was a lot of steam, is my hot water urn now a problem? Can I still consider water heated up in it pareve? Thank you […]
Pasuk for Shmone Esrei
Question: What pasuk do I say in shemoneh esrei corresponding to my name? My name in devoireh braindel bas mirel faigel Answer: For דבורה- “דאגה בלב איש ישחנה ודבר טוב ישמחנה” (משלי י”ב-כה) בריינדל- “במקהלות ברכו אלהים ד’ ממקור ישראל” (תהלים 68- 27) Sources:
Is there power to yud gimmel middos recited without a minyan and said with “trop”
Question: You posted a question about reciting the yud gimmel middos without a minyan and you posed the question, is there the same “power” to the yud gimmel middos recited alone and you never answered that. Can you please. Does the yud gimmel middos recited alone in quarantine effectuate the same koach or power as […]
Hagra on sukkot
Question: shalom. On sukkot there’s maybe something with yahrzeit of elijahu ben salomo zalman. Apart from that, do you know – or can you redirect to – any source of his (vilna gaon’s) behaviour on [ any maybe even counsel about ] sukkot? A blessed new year, Answer: Correct the yahrtzeit of the Vilna Gaon […]
forgiving or ignoring a narcissist
Question: Hi, there’s a lot of background to this question that’s nec. to show where I’m coming from for, so PLS read it all first! the question(s) is at the end. Thank you very very much! Hi, Sorry for the long question but it’s a lot of background, that’s nec. to show where I’m coming […]
Loss of smell due to covid
Question: I recently lost my smell due to covid. Do I make a bracha on bissamin by Havdalah? Answer: No you would not make a bracha. A person can be yotza havdalah even if they didn’t smell bsamim. If there is someone there that can smell, they should make the bracha and smell, but you can’t. […]
Am I allowed to buy a wood cutting board Or other wood bowls that says it is preoiled?
Question: May I buy new Wood cutting boards or bowls that are pre oiled? Answer: You may buy them, but they should be kashered, once the surface oil is removed. Have a good Yom Tov
Corn stalks used for Halloween for Schach
Question: A gardening nursery near my home is selling corn stalks for a non Jewish holiday called Halloween as a decoration. I do not know if it’s cut specifically for Halloween or not? Can it be purchased for scach l’chatchila? Please answer me ASAP. Thank you Answer: They are permitted to buy and use for […]
Learning in sukkah
Question: Do you have to learn in the sukkah? If it would be uncomfortable to do so, is there a heter to learn indoors? Thank you Answer: Essentially the ideal place to learn on Sukkos is in the sukkah because the sukkah is the place we spend our time during sukkos, If however you are […]
Donating to Hebrew free loan society – which mitzvah?
Question: Is donating a small sum to a Hebrew free loan society considered the mitzvah of tzedekah or the mitzvah of giving a loan? Answer: Essentially it is the mitzvah of giving a free loan, however if the person getting the loan is poor it would also be included in If the money is loaned […]
Fulfilling orders on Chol Hamoed
Question: Hi, is one allowed to fulfill online orders during chol hamoed? What would be the din if delaying fulfilling orders would affect your ratings, and by extension further sales? Answer: Essentially we should not be involved in business on chol hamoed unless it is needed for the chag. If not fulfilling the orders will […]
bris zoom invite
Question: Is it permitted for a person to send a zoom invitation for a bris to another person? Is that the same as inviting someone which many have the custom to not actually invite to a bris? Is there a better way of doing it? Please provide sources. Thank you! Answer: If my understanding is […]
Others potentially working on holidays
Question: Hello, I asked the assistant in my office to do something today and, because it involves multiple people and steps, it is possible that someone will end up working on it on Yom Kippur or another holiday. Is this a problem because the request came from me (even though I did not ask on […]
Fasting on Yom Kippur
Question: I had a procedure several months ago to fix an increased heart rate, since then it is mostly okay bh but it is still somewhat elevated due to anxiety about health issues, which also causes some dizziness. My doctor feels that i can fast if i drink enough on the day before the fast […]
Do i have to fast since i am still recovering from covid
Question: recovering from covid Answer: You definitely have to fast. Regarding taking shiurim of liquids, that depends on your present condition, general health etc. and it should be discussed with your local doctor and rov.. Take care of this quickly ,because Sunday is already erev Yom Kippur. Gmar chasima tova an drefuah shleima Sources: