Question: The Shulchan Aruch talks about not answering Amen to a Shaliach Tzibbur who is not “merutzeh l’kahal.” Can an individual who was exploited by said Shaliach Tzibbur and embarrassed… Read more »
Category: Chazzan’s Repetition of Shmoneh Esrei
A halachaly incorrect amen, can it work bedevid?
Question: If someone response with an amen chatufa can he yotzei himself or motzei someone else by say an incorrect amen? Answer: When being yotza with someone else’s bracha we… Read more »
If someone response with an amen chatufa did he really say amen?
Question: If someone response with an incorrect “amen”, does his amen counts like he said amen or is it considered invalid or insignificant? Thank you Answer: When answering amen we… Read more »