Question:

I don’t understand something. If there is an explicit mishna in the Yerushalmi in Chullin (3:6) to rely upon describing signs of a bird, why would there be any disagreement about the stork, including according to Rashi? Either it has the signs or it doesn’t, as indicated by Rabbenu Yerucham. On the hand, why do poskim disagree about the names and identities of birds when they can simply rely on the simanim? Thank you.

Answer:

Please see the following link  http://dinonline.org/?p=48225&preview=true which should answer your question.

Best Wishes

 

Tags: birds

Share The Knowledge

Not what you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged Kosher meat and poultry birds or ask your own question.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *