For donations Click Here

Mistaken Yaaleh Vyavo

If an individual or a tzibbur thought it was Rosh Chodrsh on the wrong day and said yaleh veyavo, they need to repeat shmonei esrei for shachris and tashlumim for mariv too, correct?


Incorrect, bdieved the tefilla is not repeated.


See Mishna Brura 108:38 at the end from the Chaye Adam that once the bracha [and certainly the entire shmone esrei] is completed, one does not go back and repeat. In the middle of a bracha one would go back to the beginning of the bracha [and in the middle of the first 3 or last 3 brachos one would go back to the beginning of that group]. However once completed, there is no going back.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *