To Donate Click Here

Leaving Zimmun for Minyan

Can you leave a zimmun (10 or 3) to daven with a minyan (no minyan later and there will be zimmun and minyan without you)?


No, it is not permitted to leave a zimmun for this purpose.

Davening with a minyan is a virtue but not a full obligation (though see Iggros Moshe Vol. 3, no. 7), whereas a zimmus is actually an obligation.

Therefore, one cannot leave a zimmun for purposes of joining a minyan (even if we see davening with a minyan as an obligation, it won’t trump the present obligation of zimmun). Please see our articles on Zimmun for more information about the obligation.

Best wishes.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *