Question:
The MB forbids asking a gentile to light candles for Neilah. Why is this not categorised as Shvus bemokom Mitzva and / or zorceh rabbim which is permitted (even though the Melocho is min Hatorah)? Thanks very much
Answer:
See Rema O:CH 276-2 that we may not ask a gentile to do a melacha d’orayso unless it is needed for many people and there is a great need. Then see and M:B 276-24 that even if there is a great need many poskim don’t allow it, and therefore it shouldn’t be done.
Best wishes
Additional reading:
- “I’m sure your package will come on Saturday afternoon.”
- Being photographed by a Non-Jew on Shabbos
- If I am catering a Shabbos job can I ask my goyim to load the truck after the shabos meal
- Asking gentile to bring Shabbos delivery inside
- Lights that need to be turned on for a simcha
- IN REGARDS TO AMIRA LAKUM IS THERE A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SHABBOS AND YOM TOV?
- Asking a goy to move muktzeh