Question: If I say kriat shema and still havent fallen asleep after 30 minutes of saying it do I say shema again ? Answer: One of the reasons why the Rema (O:CH 139-1) says that after saying kriyas shema, if one doesn’t fall asleep, he should say it numerous times, is in order that the […]
Author Archives: Rabbonim of the Beis Hora'a
Keilim touched each other
Question: I was boiling milk in a pot and it overflowed and spilled, i inmediately took the pot of the stove and accidentaly placed it my great grandmothers metal serving tray we have as decoration. Now, she was not jewish and i dont know if it had absorbed non-kosher taste. (When i took it off […]
What is the status of the garlic?
Question: If I fry in a milchig pan garlic . What is status of the garlic? Answer: The garlic will then be milchig, even if the frying pan was not used within 24hrs. This is because a sharp item, like raw garlic, absorbs and refreshes the old taste absorbed in the walls of the frying […]
kilayim: grape vine and nana
Question: Is it a problem of kilayim to have a grape vine running over a nana (spearmint?) plant, I think the Iranian Jews eat nana ? Answer: Nana is mint, and in the terms of the Mishnayos ( Sheviis 7-1) it is called “Dandana”. Mint is considered edible to humans, and therefore it would have […]
Time limitations on a co-signed check
Question: How long is the statute of limitations on a co-signed check that the signer didn’t pay and he closed the account for a check of 2,000 shekels 30 years ago. Now the co-signer wanted to renew his Israeli passport and they won’t let him because they want $10,000. Aren’t there laws in the Torah […]
100% polyester
Question: Do I need to check 100% polyester woman’s top for shatnez? Thank you Answer: Please see the following post, where a similar question was addressed. https://dinonline.org/2012/04/17/testing-polyester-suit-for-shaatnez/ Best Wishes
Chewable antacids
Question: Do non brand name chewable antacids need a hecksher? Answer: Antacids can contain ingredients that are from animal derivatives, therefore they should have a hechsher. Best wishes
Returning money put into my bank account
Question: Shalom alechem. A jew deposited more money in my account that he was supposed. I noticed him through via w app. He saw the message but did not claim the money. Should I discover his account and deposit the money or once I noticed him and he saw the message I have no Chiyuv […]
Joint Kiddush with for two sisters’ simchas
Question: Is there an issue for two sisters both celebrating birth of a baby girl to have joint kiddush? Thank you Answer: Mazal tov to the whole family! I don’t think that there is any issue with doing that. The issue would be because of ayn mearvin simcha bsimcha, however that only applies to making […]
How long do I say kaddish for?
Question: Shalom Rabbi. I have a serious problem. My mother passed away last year. I’ve been saying Kadish for her soul ever since 3 times a day plus when I go to the graveyard. On may the 10th is exactly 11 months since her departure. I have heard from some Rabbis different opinions when to […]
Birchas HaMazon motzei Rosh Chodesh
Question: Hi My son asked the following question. He washed and ate bread before shekia on Rosh Chodesh. He is about to go to Maariv and remembers he didn’t yet Bench. If he Benches now, he will be a few minutes late to Maariv. If he Benches later he will run into issue of saying […]
Music at Sheva Brachos during Sfira
Question: A friend is getting married on rosh chodesh and I am hosting a sheva brachos in the week, am I allowed to put on music or even to play live music? Answer: It is controversial if it is permitted or not. If however it is the norm in your area to have music during […]
Baby Formula and Cholov Stam
Question: My baby is 5 months old and is my wife is feeding her. Periodically it’s necessary to give the baby milk formula for example we’re going out, or to keep her used to feeding from a bottle, or when she won’t nurse. Baby formula has a very short shelf life, once open it has […]
copying for non-commercial use
Question: I was on a photo-sharing website called smugmug and saw a nice picture and i wanted to save it for personal use. (the photographer was a yid) and the picture was copyrighted. Because I’m tech-savvy i know there is a certain way to get the picture, if you the link and copy it to […]
Vaping
Question: Is juul pods kosher? Answer: It should have hechsher, and this is indeed the opinio of R’ M. Shternbuch, and other poskim in E. Yisroel. It is also the opinion of the CRC in Chicago. The reason is because it can contain ingredients that are from animal derivitives. Even if there are poskim, that […]
where is the mikur for the חז״ל צדיק גוזר והקדוש ברוך מקיים
Question: Where is the mikur for the חז״ל צדיק גוזר והקדוש ברוך מקיים Answer: The Midrash, Devorim Rabba 5-13, see also Moed Katan 16b. Have a good day.
Attending a football match during avelus for a father
Question: My boyfriend and I split up but he said he wished he could talk to me. Unfortunately there is no regular minyan in my town. His avelus ends in a few months. I found that on the bank holiday weekend there will be s visiting delegation from a yeshiva with their rabbi so we […]
withholding rental checks
Question: I leased an apartment I own in Kiryat Malachi to tenants who are withholding rental checks. I want to bring them to Din Torah. Can the hearing take place in Jerusalem or has it to take place in Kiryat Malachi. I tried contacting HaRav Yerusalavski in Kiryat Malachi who runs a beis din lemamonos, […]
If I nap during the day do I say mode ani when i wake up?
Question: if i nap during the day do i say mode ani when i wake up or just wash neigel vasser? Answer: Just wash negel vasser. We only say mode ani after the main sleep of the day, which is the nighttime sleep. Sources: See Aderes Tiferes -1 who discusses your question, and one of […]
Staying in a hotel with crucifixes?
Question: Is there any halachic problem with staying the night in a hotel containing symbols of avoda zara — such as a crucifix. On an upcoming business trip, I have been bought a hotel night at a hotel that is attached to, and managed by, a church. Although the hotel is not a church itself, […]
Blood in Breastmilk from pumping, are the plastic parts treif?
Question: When pumping, blood was noticed in the parts and in the milk. We use the microwave to sterilize the parts. Are they now treif and we cannot sterilize them using the microwave? Can we use microwave if we just wash them in cold water? Answer: The parts are still permitted to use and they do not […]
Non jewish employees in India who elect to work on Shabbos
Question: Is it permissible to hire non-Jewish employees (doing computer programming) in India engaged to any 6 days of the week if I am aware that they will most likely work on Shabbos vs work on a Sunday? Answer: It is permitted because the gentile has elected on his own to work, for his own […]
Why do we use different utensils for meat and milk?
Question: Why do we use different utensils for meat and milk? Answer: The reason that we use different utensils for milk and meat is because when a utensil is used with hot or spicy food, it absorbs its taste. That taste can then get transferred to food of the opposite type. For example, if […]
The use of credit/debit cards on Shabbos
Question: A rabbinical student told me that their use is permitted on the Sabbath as no money changes hands. It is just a promise that the bank will pay at a later time. I disagreed and said swiping the card causes an electronic spark(s). He said that handing over a credit card to the cashier […]
going to shul with bad cold
Question: Is it ok to go to shul if one has a cold and a strong cough and slight fever. the concern is that we may be spreading the cold to others. Answer: It is not ok for someone to go to shul when he is contagious and will be hurting others and causing them […]
Can a Rebbe who is in aveilus for a parent, go to his students bar mitzvas?
Question: Can a Rebbe who is in aveilus for a parent, go to his students bar mitzvas? Answer: He can attend the bar mitzva, but in a limited manner. He may attend, but he should not wear shabbos clothing, (unless his weekday clothing is not presetable). He should not partake in the meal, but he […]
Can a zeidy who is in aveilus for a parent, attend the bris of a grandson?
Question: Can a zeidy who is in aveilus for a parent, attend the bris of a grandson? Answer: A zeidy who is in aveuilus may attend his grandsons bris. He may also wear shabbos clothing, however he must remove then after the meal. Sources: The laws of Aveilus quoting Tziuney Halacha pg. 485.
juul on pesach
Question: I brought kosher lpesach juul pods my question did i need to buy a new juul for pesach(which i didnt and it was used on pesach with kosher for passover pods) or was my regular juul with kosher for passover pods good? if i wasnt allowed to use it and needed a new one […]
Maple syrup left out over pesach
Question: If one left maple syrup over pesach out in the open and then realized after pesach about it must one burn it or what should he do? Answer: Maple syrup does not contain any chometz, but it can contain kitnios. Although the minhag Ashkenaz is not to eat kitnois on Pesach nevertheless we may […]
May one start shmoneh esrei during a mincha kitzarah if he knows he won’t make Kaddish
Question: If one is davening a mincha kitzarah and he knows he won’t be able to finish shmoneh esrei before they say Kaddish shulaim, may he start shmoneh esrei or do we say amen yihei shmei rabbah is udif Answer: Essentially your question applies even when one is davening a regular shmona esrei by shacharis […]
Payment for elevator
Question: Shalom Alechem I bought an apartment in Brazil. And the building has shabos elevator that was paid by some of the residents of the building. I am moving in a week and now the residents of the building are requesting me to pay one share of the cost of the shabos elevator (approx 5.000 […]
The messiah and his arrival
Question: Hello i wanted to know more about the Messiah. I wanted to know if they might have a prophecy about a woman giving birth to the messiah. If there are no prophecy stating the messiah is being born of a woman can the messiah still be born of a woman? Instead of him being […]
Shaatnez and botil b’rove
Question: Does every wool suit or garment need to be checked for shatnez or can one rely on “Rove”, that the majority of suits and clothes do not contain shaatnez? Answer: You are asking an interesting question. Even if most suits and clothes in the world are not shatnez, however we only say that it […]
Filling up the tank of a borrowed car
Question: My mother in law lent me her car for the month I just filled up the entire tank before returning it. Is that somewhat assur because of ribbis? Thank you Answer: That was the correct thing to do, because that is simple hakaras hatov fopr the fact that she lent you her car for […]
Bris after a C-section on Yom Tov
Question: If a woman has a C-section brith 7 days before a Yom Tov. Is there any problem with making the bris on Yom Tov due to the brith not being natural. Or one must wait until after Yom Tov to preform the bris? Answer: A child that is born from a C-section does not […]
Cleaning Supplies kosher
Question: Do cleaning supplies such as Bar Keepers friend need a Hechser ? I can not find something that works as good as that item. Thank you Answer: They do not need a hechsher, as they are not at all edible, and no one is (hopefully) planning to eat it. Best Wishes
Waiting by dishes cooked together with meat
Question: If II baked kugel with yapchik(meat kugel) both open together do I have to wait 6 hrs if I eat just the plain kugel? Answer: You do not have to wait 6 hours after eatig the kugel. The reason is because the kugel was only connected to the meaty yapthick through zeah (steam), and […]
Fleishig microwave that ws used for dairy farina that spilled over, can it be kashered?
Question: I have a fleishig microwave my child put a open container dairy farina it’s spilled over, is there any way I can use the microwave again for fleishig. Answer: In general it is adviseable to have two microwaves, and not to use it for milk and meat even if the two will be covered […]
Is one allowed to sleep in a room with Christian icons which are being worshipped?
Question: Is one permitted to sleep in a room/house where there are idolatrous images on the walls, such as JC, virgin Mary, etc. (which are being worshipped – the inhabitants pray to them)? Answer: Before getting into the technical halachic aspect if it is permitted or not, it is surely not advisable to stay there […]
Is it allowed to play music (for dancing) during the Sefirat Ha Omer?
Question: By dancing, I don’t mean at a party, I mean if you’re a dancer. I’m not a professional dancer, but I dance almost every day, it’s my hobby and it’s already very difficult for me not to dance during yom tov or shabbat. Not listening to music and dancing for 33 days would be […]
Sources in chazal about the unique impact a Jew has on the world
Question: Hello Rabbi, Could you tell me some sources in Chazal that discuss the unique impact a Jew has on the world (that no other creation has), like the one that says the world would cease to exist if a Torah wasn’t being learn. Thank you! Answer: If you would like to see numerous sources […]
Answering a Jewishly-incorrect answer on standardized testing
Question: I was studying for an exam and a practice problem asked about the similarities between the Torah and the Code of Hammurabi, and asked what is the most likely reason for them. It was multiple choice format. The practice booklet said the “correct” answer is that the Torah (Hebrew Bible) borrowed from Hammurabi, clearly […]
Have science and archaeology improved our understanding of Tenach
Question: Hope you had a good Pesach. Can you think of phrases or passages in Tenach that have been understood better in light of archaeological or scientific discoveries? The link throws some light on the phrase “Strong hand and outstretched arm” https://www.pinterest.cl/pin/409264684881810369/ Answer: I can not access the link that you sent. Regarding your question, […]
Attending a wedding during Sefira
Question: A close friend of mine observes the latter mourning period of Sefira, beginning after Rosh Chodesh. I observe the earlier period, ending with Lag Ba’omer. My friend is getting married before Rosh Chodesh. May I attend the wedding? Thank you! Answer: Yes you may attend. R’ Moshe Feinstein explains that the reason is because […]
Pesach in time of Beis Hamikdash
Question: I was wondering how we understand whether during the First or Second Temple what was going on in Yerushalayim at the time of Pesach. Let’s assume there were half a million people or more coming in. Where was there sufficient locations for each separate chabura of 30 people to be together to eat a […]
Status of children of a convert who never kept mitsvot
Question: B”H Shalom K’vod Ha Rav, I am writing you to ask you a question regarding my situation. My father Z”L was Israeli and halachically Jewish. He wasn’t observant however, although he was very knowledgeable on Halacha. My mother is a convert (she did an orthodox giyur, registered with the — Beit Din). Yet, in line […]
Calculating Sheloshim
Question: I cannot determine whether Pesach ended my period of Sheloshim or not. I believe it has to do with whether or not my period of shiva had already ended. The funeral was on Sunday, April 14. Pesach began on Friday evening, April 19. I believe then that Sheloshim ends on May 12. Can you […]
Cleansing a synagogue sanctuary
Question: What does a congregation do when an animal soils the inside of a shul? Answer: It should be cleaned up as soon as possible. There are certain animals that their refuse does not have a bad odor, such as dog poop, and technically will not disturb the prayers if it doesn’t smell bad, nevertheless […]
Shave on Erev pesach
Question: Is there a heter to shave Erev Pesach after chatzos (without a goy)? Answer: I didn’t receive your question until it was already Yom Tov in E. Yisroel… but at least you’ll have the answer for next year. In most instances it is not permitted. The reason being that erev Pesach is considered like […]
Shul
Question: Is there a mitzva of just sitting in shul and not davening or learning? Just being in shul. Thanks Answer: You are asking an interesting question. I once heard R’ Avogdor Miller Zt”l talk about this, and he said that indeed there is a mitzva by just sitting in a shul, even if you […]