Question: Ha Rav, I covered urine on the floor of the Shul toilet with a paper towel . I then inadvertently stepped on the paper towel, was it Chillul Shabbos for S’chitah (squeezing)? Answer: Hello, In retrospect we will not say that it was chillul Shabbos. Sechita can be one of two melachos, either […]
Author Archives: Rabbonim of the Beis Hora'a
Shmitta regarding Bananas
Question: My son asked me a question that i did not know the answer to. Why is there no Issur Sfichin (prohibition to eat vegetables that were grown in Eretz Yisroel during Shmitta) on bananas. That since we make a Ha’Adomah on it shouldn’t it be included? I have seen bananas on sale here in […]
Smelling woman’s perfume on the bus
Question: Hi Rabbi! On the bus when I commute sometimes a lady might sit herself down a few seats away and I am able to smell the perfume. It’s not so simple to just get up and move. I can’t hold my breath for the entire time (or wear a scuba diving mask). I definitely […]
Pareve knife
Question: Hi. Maybe you can help me. I cut and peeled a dakon (like a big radish) with a clean dairy knife two days ago and yesterday I peeled and cut up the rest with a pareve knife. Do I have to consider the pareve knife dairy from now on? Answer: Hello, You do […]
Lashon hara
Question: Hi, The IT dept in my (Jewish) company is considered to be quite incompetent and frustrating by many (most?) of my coworkers. They’re quite a large dept with many IT subdivisions. Am I allowed to slip in a snide remark when a messup occurs again? It’s not known or will become known who was […]
Haftorah from Klaf
Question: A gutten, We have a novi written on Klaf – Sefer Shoftim. This week is Parshas Shelach in Chutz LoOretz. Would it make sense to make up our own haftorah from Sefer Shoftim which has a connection to the Parsha (in שופטים א,כ it says ויתנו לכלב את חברון) and lein this from the […]
Can you take Covid antigen test on Shabbos
Question: Hi Rabbi, Can you take a Covid rapid antigen test on Shabbos? What if you are experiencing no symptoms? Mild symptoms? Thank you Answer: In general we do not take rapid covid tests o Shabbos because the lines of the results are considered roshem, part of meleches kosaiv. If someone has an acute […]
May I tell my boss about a damaging co-worker?
Question: Am I allowed to tell my boss about a coworker who is causing most other employees to leave (some left already) as well as I’m also thinking to leave due to this employee’s bad middos like putting down others, while acting extra nice to the boss so the boss thinks she’s amazing. Basically the […]
Movie tickets
Question: Is it ok to buy child tickets to a movie instead of adult tickets if you are of the adult age? Answer: Hello, Without getting into the subject of going to the movies in the first place. If they sell adult tickets for a higher price, then buying a child’s ticket, is fooling […]
lotus spread
Question: What is the bracha on lotus spread – it says its made of lotus cookies – but is a smooth spread like peanut butter, when eaten on its own? Answer: Hello, At first glance, the lotus spread is made of 58% cookies, which would be a bout 50% flour, therefore it would appear that […]
Brocho on Olives in a Salad
Question: If Sliced olives are added as a topping in a Salad (Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Chicken Pieces) with dressing, is a separate brocho made on the olives? What about the Chicken? Answer: Hi, If the pieces of chicken and olives are small and they are eaten in the same spoonful as the rest of […]
Interrupting to say Kaddish, when you are slower than the Minyan.
Question: May one interrupt any part of davening to say kaddish? Or are there specific parts where it would be forbidden to stop? Answer: Hello, Let’s go through the various parts of davening. During Pesukei D’zimra, essentially one should also not say kaddish. However, the poskim say that a child saying kaddish for a […]
Tallis fell off – new beracha?
Question: Hi, do I make a new beracha if my Tallis falls off during davening to floor? Your site seems to say two conflicting answers? According your answer here do: https://dinonline.org/2021/03/12/mezuza-4/ According to your answer here you don’t: https://dinonline.org/2021/09/12/new-brocha-when-tallis-falls-off/ Answer: Good question. Th Shulchan Aruch 8-15 writes that if one’s tallis falls off that […]
Mezuza on small room
Question: A gutten I have a small bedroom with a sloping roof. It has a shiur of 4×4 Amos x 10 tefochim high in a square shape, but only according to Reb Chaim Noeh shiur. According to the Chazon Ish shiur, it has 4×4 only in a rectangle but not in a square. Which side […]
Owner wont take money due to him
Question: Hi Rabbi We use a company to fix our swimming pool, these are usually small fixes and don’t cost a lot of money, The owner is very successful and these small amounts don’t make a difference to him We will often have to ask two or three times for a bill or ask him […]
Learning music from an idolator
Question: I was learning to play an instrument online and then found out the teacher practices occultism. Am I being foolish in not wanting to learn from him anymore despite his ability to teach? Does learning something like music from a teacher with corrupt views affect me spiritually? Thank you. Answer: Hi, Without getting […]
מי שפרע for rental agreement.
Question: Shalom uvracha, We are currently renting an apartment while simultaneously building an apartment. Our contract in the rental was for 1 year with the hope that we would be able to move into our new home by the end of the rental contract. The building process took longer than expected and our landlord asked […]
Krias shemah
Question: May I please ask you a question ? I am already a zaken (between 60 and 70), and I have never received a satisfactory answer to the following questions. Where is the source of the mitzvah de’oraisah of krias Shemah ? The Torah refers to “hadevarim ha’eileh”, a noun. Then the next posuk uses […]
Interruptions regarding Keriat Shema Al HaMita
Question: Hi Rabbi, I have a couple questions about Keriat Shema Al HaMita: Firstly, is typing an email or text message after reciting Bedtime Shema considered a Hefsek? Also, if one feels that he cannot fall asleep after reciting Bedtime Shema, would it be permitted to take melatonin supplements, even if they are flavored? Thank […]
Exercising on stone floor
Question: Shalom. Is one permitted to do push ups directly on a cement floor? Arms are somewhat spread out, but the legs are not. Thank you. Answer: It is permitted to do pushups even on a stone or cement floor. The reason is because you do not mean to prostrate yourself in a kneeling […]
Mikvah and Shalm Bayis
Question: Am I obligated to go to the mikvah if my husband does not want to have relations? Answer: Yes, you should still go to the mikva, even though you won’t have relations with your husband. From a halachic angle, going to the mikva will allow handing things to each other, and other forms […]
Repentance for anger at parent
Question: B”H Kavod haRav, 1. Regarding repenting for getting angry at a parent, if the person apologizes to the parent and they forgive them, and the person does teshuva (on the day of the mistake) to Hashem for getting angry/ not properly honoring parent, does any part of the sin remain “on their record?” 2. […]
Signing Ketubah
Question: Is it permitted for witnesses to sign a ketubah with their first and last name? Meaning they sign as on a normal government or financial document without mentioning “ben ploni”. If this was already done on someone’s ketubah is that fine? Answer: Hello, When the witnesses sign their names, they should write their […]
Pets and tzar balei chaim
Question: I’d like to know if and how the mitzvah of tzar balei chaim would apply to small pets? For instance, when kids get chicks to raise, or a rabbit as a pet, or salamanders. Is it okay to purchase these animals if they may die sooner or later due to unintentional negligence? How much […]
Jewelry on Shabbat
Question: B”H Kavod haRav, Thank you for your help. 1. If a lady is wearing a ring on Shabbat that makes an indentation on her skin (for example the shape of a heart), and then decides to take the ring on and off over Shabbat, is this an issue of erasing/ writing? 2. If a […]
Eating food outdoors
Question: Is there any issue with bugs flying or crawling into food that is either being eaten outside or kept outside? Even though it would seem that any bug that managed to make it into the food would easily be able to escape when the food is being eaten, this does not seem to be […]
lashon hara
Question: B”H Kavod haRav, I am in the process of trying to learn more about kosher cooking and kosher meat. I was in a kosher supermarket and asked a lady near me if it was ok that there was red liquid near some of the cut meat. I said that I don’t know cooking, indicating […]
Does one need separate trivets for meat and milk?
Question: A trivet is a small plate placed under a hot serving dish to protect a table or surface. Can one have only one trivet, and use it interchangeably to place meat or milk pots on it? Answer: You should get separate trivets for milk and meat. The reason is because often the bottom […]
Follow up question
Question: I had asked previously about putting a hot bowl on a treif counter. The rabbi answered that it’s not lechatchila, and brought sources. I would like to ask, that none of those sources deal with a case of the bottom surface being cold and the top (bowl) being hot, therefore there is no tata’ah […]
Being peaceful around someone who provokes you
Question: Hello Rabbi, There is someone in my life, close to me, that I have to be around a lot. But most of the times we are together we get into a conflict. I don’t know what to call it, we lack chemistry, our energies are not compatible. Everything I say she pokes at and […]
How to name a newborn BOY after Isaiah 54:2-3
Question: I am a beginner in Hebrew. how to NAME a boy after the idea that matches with Isaiah 54:2-3 “GOD HAS ENLARGED MY TENT” ? Could you help please? Answer: Hi, My apologies, but those verses don’t discuss the topic about God enlarging one’s tent. Nevertheless if you want to give a name […]
Asking a non-Jew to early check in on Shabbos
Question: My wife and I will be flying early Sunday morning, check in opens 24 hours before (on Shabbos). My wife will be quite heavily pregnant and is suffering from it. I would very much like to ensure I can sit next to her to assist her during the flight. If we don’t check in […]
Using Windex on Shabbos
Question: Is one allowed to spray Windex on a very smudged glass storm door and wipe it off on Shabbos, either with cloth or paper-towel? Is one allowed to spray a cleanser on dirty counter/table top on Shabbos and wipe it clean (paper or cloth)? Answer: Hello, The poskim say that it is permitted […]
Items not picked up by customer
Question: Hello, I am a product photographer People bring me products and many times they don’t pick it up I end up having a full warehouse of products for 10th of clients. I state on each invoice i send a disclaimer “products not picked up within 30 days will be thrown away” My Question is: […]
Do I owe any money?
Question: I was trying to rent my apartment so I contacted an attorney I know to ask her a few questions about what I might include in the contract. I thought I might use her to write the contract. Finally, when I got a tenant my agent told me he has a contract everyone uses […]
Lying when advertising
Question: Hi, I’m strongly considering a career in copywriting (which involves writing to promote a product or service, generally in the attempt to have people purchase something or sign up for something etc. It can be business to business, or business to customer, such as sales letters). There are times when such materials are clearly […]
Tachanun in a side room
Question: Hi! If Mincha is davened in a side room of a shul, which is normally used for kids programs, where there are no Sifrei Torah or Seforim, only siddurim, do we put our head down? Answer: Hello, We put our heads down during tachanun if the room has a sefer torah, or if […]
Maaser on Mortgage Principal – Periodically or Upon Sale of
Question: Topic: When does Maaser need to be calculated and paid on the portion of a mortgage payment that pays down principal? Supporting Info: When refinancing a mortgage and pulling out some money in the process one does not have to pay Maaser on that money since it is technically a loan that will be […]
טעות עכום for a public company
Question: Hi, I purchased an item from Macy’s, which is a publicly owned company and probably has Jewish shareholders. They accidentally charged me less than the actual price. Do I have to go out of my way to pay it back. Or since it is טעות עכום, can I keep the money? Thank you. […]
Spraying deodorizer on foul smell
Question: If I want to daven in a room that has laundry that smells bad if I cover the laundry so now it’s miscasya like the halcha says I should if it still smells may I spray febreze like on the halcha permits with smell with no Ikur since it’s covered or no even though […]
Challah using rice or corn together with one of the five grains
Question: How much rice flour can we use in rye or oats (cereals of the five species) to make challah with less gluten ? Answer: Hello, Before answering your question, let’s go through the halachos regarding mixing flour of the five grains with other non-grain flour. Any mixture between one if the five grains […]
Didn’t say tachanun
Question: What happen if I don’t say tachanun and how do I do teshuva for it? Answer: Hello, Tachanun is considered like a part of Shemona Esrei, in the sense that we daven to Hashem standing, falling on our face, and sitting. If you didn’t say it, there isn’t much to do aside from regular […]
Reselling bought items
Question: Is one allowed to buy items online for the purpose of reselling them? Thank You! Answer: Hello, Unless I am missing something, I don’t see why not. If there is a stipulation or some other condition, rule or law against buying in order to resell the items, I don’t see why you shouldn’t […]
Wrinkle Spray on Shabbos
Question: Is it permitted to use a wrinkle release spray on an item of clothing on Shabbos in order to remove creases? Answer: Hello, Using the spray to remove wrinkles is problematic on Shabbos. This is even if the spray doesn’t have a scent, and even if the creases are not so bad that […]
Thank you
Question: I just want to thank the Rov again for all the support and help. Thank you very much Answer: You’re welcome Sources:
Mechitza erection on Shabbos
Question: Can a mechitza be put up on Shabbos to daven Answer: Hello, If the mechitzah is only a temporary partition according to most poskim it is permitted.it is. Th explanation is this. Part of the melacha of ohel, is not to make walls on Shabbos. The Shulchan Aruch writes that a temporary partition […]
Tefillah betzibbur OR kavono?
Question: finish MB in siman 51 sk 20 that if its extremely cold one should rather daven with kavonoh at home than be`tzibbur in v cold conditions. Dont we generally say that tefilah betzibbur is doche better kavonoh? Answer: Hello, What you are writing is correct, that in general we don’t say that one […]
Birkas Hatorah
Question: Why is the recital of the pessukim after our daily Birkas Hatorah considered “learnig” whilst in reality there is no actual learning taking place? Answer: Hello, Reading pesukim of the Torah is considered Torah learning, even if tit wasn’t learned with Rashi etc. Best wishes
Ripping kriyah at the kotel on days that we don’t say tachanun
Question: Is there a minhag in Yerushalayim not to rip kriyah on a day that tachnun is not said? If yes, what would be the source? Answer: Hello, There is controversy if there is such a minhag or not, however even if there would be such a minhag, it is not specifically a minhag […]
“Fasten Your seat belt” procedure in the air plane.
Question: Rabbonim of The Din Online: I have the question. Namely, the following: I was taking a flight from Dortmund to Tel Aviv. And, of course, I was very glad to fasten the seat belt, when needed / when was the time for the air flight security reasons. 1. Should the tussles, The Threads, the […]